"Our wedding was obviously the best day of our lives — it was so magical," Pitt tells PEOPLE Bachelor in Paradise sweethearts Serena Pitt and Joe Amabile appear to still be in their honeymoon phase.

"We just don’t know If it’s going to be our forever place'," Pitt tells PEOPLE about the married 'Bachelor in Paradise' couple's current home of New York City Monica Schipper/Getty Joe Amabile and ...